| Gathering Frost | Kaitlyn Davis | Once Upon a Curse #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| All Our Yesterdays | Cristin Terrill | | 4 Stars |
| Return Once More | Trisha Leigh | The Historians #1 | 4 Stars |
| Love Me Never | Sara Wolf | Lovely Vicious #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| Cheerleading Can Be Murder | Carissa Ann Lynch | Horror High #1 | 4 Stars |
| Withering Rose | Kaitlyn Davis | Once Upon a Curse #2 | 4 Stars |
| Rhodi's Light | Megan Linski | The Rhodi Saga #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Rhodi Rising | Megan Linski | The Rhodi Saga #2 | 3.5 Stars |
| Rhodi's Lullaby | Megan Linski | The Rhodi Saga #3 | 3.5 Stars |
| Under A Million Stars | Rita Branches | | 4 Stars |
| Forget Me Always | Sara Wolf | Lovely Vicious #2 | 4 Stars |
| Imperfectly Criminal | Mary Frame | Imperfect #2 | 4 Stars |
| Remember Me Forever | Sara Wolf | Lovely Vicious #3 | 4 Stars |
| Epic Crush of Genie Lo, The | F.C. Yee | The Epic Crush of Genie Lo #1 | 5 Stars |
| Black Bird of the Gallows | Meg Kassel | Black Birds of the Gallows #1 | 4 Stars |
| Sky Throne, The | Chris Ledbetter | The Sky Throne #1 | 4 Stars |
| Shatter Me | Tahereh Mafi | Shatter Me #1 | 2.5 Stars |
| Let's Talk About Love | Claire Kann | | 5 Stars |
| Beyond the Red | Ava Jae | Beyond the Red #1 | 4 Stars |
| This Tiny Perfect World | Lauren Gibaldi | | 3.5 Stars |
| Fire and Bone | Rachel A. Marks | Otherborn #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Bring Me Their Hearts | Sara Wolf | Bring Me Their Hearts #1 | 4 Stars |
| #Murdertrending | Gretchen McNeil | #MurderTrending #1 | 4 Stars |
| American Panda | Gloria Chao | | 4.5 Stars |
| Keeper of the Bees | Meg Kassel | Black Birds of the Gallows #2 | 4.5 Stars |
| Echoes | Alice Reeds | | 2.5 Stars |
| Perfect Harmony | Emily Albright | | 3 Stars |
| Three Mages and a Margarita | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Spellbound #1, Guild Codex Universe #1 | 5 Stars |
| Blade So Black, A | L.L. McKinney | The Nightmare-Verse #1 | 1.5 Stars |
| Dark Arts and a Daiquiri | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Spellbound #2, Guild Codex Universe #2 | 4.5 Stars |
| Strange the Dreamer | Laini Taylor | Strange the Dreamer #1 | 2 Stars |
| Death by the River | Alexandrea Weis, Lucas Astor | | 1.5 Stars |
| Dream Keeper | Amber R. Duell | The Dark Dreamer #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| White Stag | Kara Barbieri | Permafrost #1 | 3 Stars |
| Girl King, The | Mimi Yu | The Girl King #1 | 2 Stars |
| Heartbreakers, The | Ali Novak | The Heartbreakers Chronicles #1 | 4 Stars |
| All Is Fair | Dee Garretson | | 3 Stars |
| Cruel Prince, The | Holly Black | The Folk of the Air #1 | 2 Stars |
| Flame Queen, The | Dax Munro | The Legends of Peradon #1 | 1 Star |
| Two Witches and a Whiskey | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Spellbound #3, Guild Codex Universe #3 | 5 Stars |
| Last of Her Name | Jessica Khoury | | 4 Stars |
| Pretend She's Here | Luanne Rice | | 3.5 Stars |
| #Starstruck | Sariah Wilson | #Lovestruck #1 | 5 Stars |
| Opposite of Always | Justin A. Reynolds | | 5 Stars |
| Shadow Glass, The | Rin Chupeco | The Bone Witch #3 | 4.5 Stars |
| Golden Curse | M. Lynn | Fantasy and Fairytales #1 | 1 Star |
| #Moonstruck | Sariah Wilson | #Lovestruck #2 | 2.5 Stars |
| Sky Without Stars | Jessica Brody, Joanne Rendell | System Divine #1 | 4 Stars |
| Demon Magic and a Martini | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Spellbound #4, Guild Codex Universe #4 | 4.5 Stars |
| Through the White Wood | Jessica Leake | | 3.5 Stars |
| Smoke and Key | Kelsey Sutton | | 4 Stars |
| Rebellious Sister, The | Sarah Noffke, Michael Anderle | Unstoppable Liv Beaufont #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Don't Bet on Love | Victorine E. Lieske | Rockford High #1 | 1.5 Stars |
| I Dare You | Ilsa Madden-Mills | The Hook Up #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| Robbergirl | S.T. Gibson | | 3.5 Stars |
| Secrets of a Fangirl | Erin Dionne | | 5 Stars |
| Prince's Prisoner, The | Klarissa King, Isla Jones | Feared Fables #2 | 3 Stars |
| Red Winter | Annette Marie | Red Winter #1 | 2.5 Stars |
| Chosen, The | Taran Matharu | Contender #1 | 3 Stars |
| Spin the Dawn | Elizabeth Lim | The Blood of Stars #1, Legends of Lor'yan | 5 Stars |
| Phantom Forest, The | Liz Kerin | | 4 Stars |
| Storm and Fury | Jennifer L. Armentrout | The Harbringer #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Chasing Midnight | Kaitlyn Davis | Once Upon a Curse #3 | 4.5 Stars |
| Wicked King, The | Holly Black | The Folk of the Air #2 | 5 Stars |
| Dragon Warrior, The | Katie Zhao | The Dragon Warrior #1 | 5 Stars |
| Our Wayward Fate | Gloria Chao | | 4 Stars |
| Soul of the Sword | Julie Kagawa | Shadow of the Fox #2 | 3.5 Stars |
| Kingdom of the Blazing Phoenix | Julie C. Dao | Rise of the Empress #2 | 4 Stars |
| #Awestruck | Sariah Wilson | #Lovestruck #3 | 1 Star |
| Bookworm Crush, The | Lisa Brown Roberts | | 4.5 Stars |
| First Year | Rachel E. Carter | The Black Mage #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Taming Demons for Beginners | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Demonized #1, Guild Codex Universe #5 | 4.5 Stars |
| Shrouded Kingdom | Rachel Medhurst | The Lost Queen of Althea #1 | 1.5 Stars |
| Parting Worlds | Kaitlyn Davis | Once Upon a Curse #4 | 4.5 Stars |
| Feather | Olivia Wildenstein | Angels of Elysium #1 | 4 Stars |
| Spellhacker | M.K. England | | 3.5 Stars |
| Grail | Realm Lovejoy | Le Fay #3 | 3.5 Stars |
| Shadow Frost | Coco Ma | Shadow Frost #1 | 2 Stars |
| Geekerella | Ashley Poston | Once Upon a Con #1 | 4 Stars |
| Jade City | Fonda Lee | The Green Bone Saga #1 | 4 Stars |
| Between Burning Worlds | Jessica Brody, Joanne Rendell | System Divine #2 | 4.5 Stars |
| Night of the Dragon | Julie Kagawa | Shadow of the Fox #3 | 5 Stars |
| One of Us Is Lying | Karen M. McManus | One of Us Is Lying #1 | 5 Stars |
| Comeback | Lyn Ashwood, Rachel Rose | | 4 Stars |
| Feast of the Mother | Miranda Honfleur, Nicolette Andrews | Witch of the Lake #1 | 3 Stars |
| Unhoneymooners, The | Christina Lauren | | 4.5 Stars |
| Cursed Key, The | Miranda Brock, Rebecca Hamilton | The Cursed Key #1 | 1 Star |
| Live Like Legends | Kate Cornell | | 2.5 Stars |
| Forest of Souls | Lori M. Lee | Shamanborn #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Unravel the Dusk | Elizabeth Lim | The Blood of Stars #2, Legends of Lor'yan | 4 Stars |
| Storyteller's Daughter, The | Victoria McCombs | Storyteller's Series #1 | 3 Stars |
| Good for Nothings, The | Danielle Banas | | 4 Stars |
| River Witch, The | Helena Rookwood | The River Witch #1 | 2 Stars |
| My Summer of Love and Misfortune | Lindsay Wong | | 1 Star |
| Warping Minds & Other Misdemeanors | Annette Marie, Rob Jacobsen | The Guild Codex: Warped #1, Guild Codex Universe #11 | 4 Stars |
| Where Dreams Descend | Janella Angeles | Kingdom of Cards #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Realm of Knights | Jennifer Anne Davis | Knights of the Realm #1 | 2 Stars |
| Princess and the Fangirl, The | Ashley Poston | Once Upon a Con #2 | 4 Stars |
| I Love You So Mochi | Sarah Kuhn | | 5 Stars |
| Last Angel Warrior, The | John W. Wells III | The Kalib Andrews Chronicles #1 | 2.5 Stars |
| 172 Hours on the Moon | Johan Harstad | | 3 Stars |
| Find Me Their Bones | Sara Wolf | Bring Me Their Hearts #2 | 3.5 Stars |
| Send Me Their Souls | Sara Wolf | Bring Me Their Hearts #3 | 4 Stars |
| Lost Wonderland Diaries, The | J. Scott Savage | The Lost Wonderland Diaries #1 | 4 Stars |
| These Violent Delights | Chloe Gong | These Violent Delights #1 | 5 Stars |
| Grave Humor | R.J. Blain | | 1.5 Stars |
| Alchemist and an Amaretto, The | Annette Marie | The Guild Codex: Spellbound #5, Guild Codex Universe #6 | 4 Stars |
| How to Save an Undead Life | Hailey Edwards | The Beginner's Guide to Necromancy #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Woods of Silver and Light | Victoria McCombs | Storyteller's Series #2 | 4 Stars |
| Iron Raven, The | Julie Kagawa | The Iron Fey: Evenfall #1, The Iron Fey #8 | 4.5 Stars |
| Spear | Realm Lovejoy | Le Fay #4 | 2.5 Stars |
| This Golden Flame | Emily Victoria | | 3.5 Stars |
| Wallflower | Cookie O'Gorman | | 4 Stars |
| After the Fall | E.C. Myers | RWBY #1 | 3 Stars |
| Into the Dim | Janet B. Taylor | Into the Dim #1 | 3 Stars |
| Ones We're Meant to Find, The | Joan He | | 3 Stars |
| Bias | Lucy Gold | | 3 Stars |
| Last Fallen Star, The | Graci Kim | Gifted Clans #1 | 5 Stars |
| We Hunt the Flame | Hafsah Faizal | Sands of Arawiya #1 | 3 Stars |
| If I Never Met You | Mhairi McFarlane | | 2.5 Stars |
| Descendant of the Crane | Joan He | | 4 Stars |
| Siri, Who Am I? | Sam Tschida | | 2 Stars |
| Celestial | Olivia Wildenstein | Angels of Elysium #2 | 4 Stars |
| Six Crimson Cranes | Elizabeth Lim | Six Crimson Cranes #1, Legends of Lor'yan | 4 Stars |
| Frankly in Love | David Yoon | Frankly in Love #1 | 2.5 Stars |
| Don't Read the Comments | Eric Smith | | 3.5 Stars |
| Queen of Nothing, The | Holly Black | The Folk of the Air #3 | 4 Stars |
| XOXO | Axie Oh | | 4 Stars |
| Idol Gossip | Alexandra Leigh Young | | 4 Stars |
| Iron Widow | Xiran Jay Zhao | Iron Widow #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Keeper of Night, The | Kylie Lee Baker | The Keeper of Night #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Iron Will of Genie Lo, The | F.C. Yee | The Epic Crush of Genie Lo #2 | 3.5 Stars |
| You Should See Me in a Crown | Leah Johnson | | 5 Stars |
| I'll Be the One | Lyla Lee | | 4 Stars |
| Song of Wraiths and Ruin, A | Roseanne A. Brown | A Song of Wraiths and Ruin #1 | 5 Stars |
| Never Tilting World, The | Rin Chupeco | The Never Tilting World #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| Court of Miracles, The | Kester Grant | A Court of Miracles #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| Evil Queen, The | Gena Showalter | The Forest of Good and Evil #1 | 2 Stars |
| Tiger Honor | Yoon Ha Lee | Thousand Worlds #2 | 4 Stars |
| Iron Sword, The | Julie Kagawa | The Iron Fey: Evenfall #2, The Iron Fey #9 | 3.5 Stars |
| How We Fall Apart | Katie Zhao | How We Fall Apart #1 | 3 Stars |
| Winter Charlatan, The | Victoria McCombs | Storyteller's Series #3 | 4 Stars |
| Jade Legacy | Fonda Lee | The Green Bone Saga #3 | 5 Stars |
| Non-Heir | Rachel E. Carter | The Black Mage #0.5 | 4 Stars |
| Apprentice | Rachel E. Carter | The Black Mage #2 | 3 Stars |
| Candidate | Rachel E. Carter | The Black Mage #3 | 4 Stars |
| Last Stand | Rachel E. Carter | The Black Mage #4 | 4.5 Stars |
| Fallen Hero, The | Katie Zhao | The Dragon Warrior #2 | 4 Stars |
| Forgery of Roses, A | Jessica S. Olson | | 3.5 Stars |
| K-Pop Revolution | Stephan Lee | K-Pop Confidential #2 | 4 Stars |
| Shinji Takahashi and the Mark of the Coatl | Julie Kagawa | Society of Explorers and Adventurers #1 | 4 Stars |
| How Moon Fuentez Fell in Love with the Universe | Raquel Vasquez Gilliland | | 5 Stars |
| Zachary Ying and the Dragon Emperor | Xiran Jay Zhao | | 5 Stars |
| Brilliant Night of Stars and Ice, A | Rebecca Connolly | | 4.5 Stars |
| Last Fallen Moon, The | Graci Kim | Gifted Clans #2 | 5 Stars |
| Feather and Flame | Livia Blackburne | The Queen's Council #2 | 4 Stars |
| Rent a Boyfriend | Gloria Chao | | 3 Stars |
| All of Us Villains | Amanda Foody, C.L. Herman | All of Us Villains #1 | 5 Stars |
| Chain of Gold | Cassandra Clare | The Last Hours #1, Shadowhunters Chronicles | 3 Stars |
| Beating Heart Baby | Lio Min | | 4 Stars |
| Dragon's Promise, The | Elizabeth Lim | Six Crimson Cranes #2, Legends of Lor'yan | 4 Stars |
| Secrets of the Looking Glass | J. Scott Savage | The Lost Wonderland Diaries #2 | 4 Stars |
| Empress of Time, The | Kylie Lee Baker | The Keeper of Night #2 | 4 Stars |
| Last of the Talons | Sophie Kim | Talon #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Dragonfly Eyes | Cao Wenxuan | | 4 Stars |
| Matchmaker's Royal Mess, The | Frieda J. Downing | | 4 Stars |
| Deadly Education, A | Naomi Novik | The Scholomance #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Cup and the Prince, The | Day Leitao | Kingdom of Curses and Shadows #1 | 2.5 Stars |
| Curse and the Prince, The | Day Leitao | Kingdom of Curses and Shadows #2 | 2 Stars |
| Because of Us | Nina Arada | | 4.5 Stars |
| Atlas Six, The | Olivie Blake | Atlas #1 | 2 Stars |
| Her Radiant Curse | Elizabeth Lim | Legends of Lor'yan | 3.5 Stars |
| Fourth Wing | Rebecca Yarros | The Empyrean #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Last Fallen Realm, The | Graci Kim | Gifted Clans #3 | 4 Stars |
| Swear on This Life | Renee Carlino | | 1 Star |
| Princess in Theory, A | Alyssa Cole | Reluctant Royals #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| All of Our Demise | Amanda Foody, C.L. Herman | All of Us Villains #2 | 4 Stars |
| Iron Flame | Rebecca Yarros | The Empyrean #2 | 1.5 Stars |
| Five Broken Blades | Mai Corland | The Broken Blades #1 | 4 Stars |
| Wrath of the Talon | Sophie Kim | Talon #2 | 4 Stars |
| Heavenbreaker | Sara Wolf | | 5 Stars |
| Only a Monster | Vanessa Len | Only a Monster #1 | 3 Stars |
| Funny Story | Emily Henry | | 4.5 Stars |
| Never a Hero | Vanessa Len | Only a Monster #2 | 2 Stars |
| Red String Theory | Lauren Kung Jessen | | 4 Stars |
| Last Graduate, The | Naomi Novik | The Scholomance #2 | 4 Stars |
| Talk Bookish to Me | Kate Bromley | | 2.5 Stars |
| Stars and Smoke | Marie Lu | Stars and Smoke #1 | 4 Stars |
| Little Witch Academia, Vol. 1 | Yoh Yoshinari | Little Witch Academia #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Zodiac Rising | Katie Zhao | Descendants of the Zodiac #1 | 2 Stars |
| Last One, The | Rachel Howzell Hall | | 3 Stars |
| Cat + Gamer, Vol. 1 | Wataru Nadatani | Cat + Gamer #1 | 5 Stars |
| My Happy Marriage, Vol. 1 | Akumi Agitogi | My Happy Marriage #1 | 5 Stars |
| Mashle: Magic and Muscles, Vol. 1 | Hajime Komoto | Mashle #1 | 5 Stars |
| Evil Secret Society of Cats, Vol. 1, The | Pandania | The Evil Secret Society of Cats #1 | 3 Stars |
| Games Gods Play, The | Abigail Owen | The Crucible #1 | 4 Stars |
| Heaven Official's Blessing: Tian Guan Ci Fu (Novel) Vol. 1 | Mò Xiāng Tóng Xiù | Heaven Official’s Blessings: Tiān Guān Cì Fú #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Deep End | Ali Hazelwood | | 4 Stars |
| Your Life Has Been Delayed | Michelle I. Mason | | 3.5 Stars |
| Great Big Beautiful Life | Emily Henry | | 4.5 Stars |
| Fateless | Julie Kagawa | Fateless #1 | 3.5 Stars |
| Immortal Consequences | I.V. Marie | The Souls of Blackwood Academy #1 | 5 Stars |
| Cat Who Saved Books, The | Sōsuke Natsukawa | The Cat Who... #1 | 4.5 Stars |
| Things Gods Break, The | Abigail Owen | The Crucible #2 | 5 Stars |
